Taylor Swift
Red
Reviewed by Chris Panico
Much like the rest of her career, Taylor Swift’s album Red contains a mixed bag of great songs, middle-of-the-road songs, and bad songs. Unfortunately, the album stepped off on one of the lesser tracks, “We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together”. The first single, as well a few other selections off the album, is over the top with its mainstream pop sound, trivial lyrics, and over enunciated singing. Luckily, this isn’t a reflection of the album as a whole. In many cases Taylor Swift has shown an extreme level of new-found maturity, particularly with her lyrics. She has a notorious streak of writing about run-of-the-mill teen romance (and presenting it in a run-of-the-mill teenage way). With Red, she breaks her juvenile habits a bit. “All Too Well” particularly shows a steadier hand with lyrics, incorporating imagistic lines such as, “Here we are again in the middle of the night/ Dancing around the kitchen in the refrigerator light”. Unfortunately, Red attempts to cater to far too many audiences over the course of its sixteen tracks. The album is a jumble of indie-powerpop-acoustic-country-rock, and even a tiny bit of electronic music (slightly reminiscent of dubstep). Whether the creative choices were Swift’s or her label’s, I don’t know. It does, however, make it hard for the entire album to be appealing all the way through.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
I agree Chris! Great review! I think that she is trying to cater to too many audiences – with this comes the opportunity for let down. However, I think that for people with a broad range of musical taste and die hard Taylor fans, it’s a new and different listen.
Thanks! I definitely think there was some let down in the album. But there were some awesome surprises too. The problem is that the wide variety makes it difficult for anyone to like the entire record.
16 tracks? No pop album should be that long…jeez.